Setting different markup id for reusable same element


Hi, I am integrating prebuilt layouts like sliders, parallax etc in a builder made with custom fields (i use carbon fields with complex field that does the same as ACF flexible content).

In the beginning i was putting a custom field for classes but finally i find it a little messy.

So i have decided to write the html with the beans functions so i can modificate the attributes with the markup id.

The problem is that my layouts are reusable, so if for exemple i use 2 times the slider but i want to configure it differently (for ex having a different animation), the 2 sliders will have the same markupid, so my modification will affect both.

So i imagine something like it is done with the beans widgets, if i put 2 text widgets the second will have [_text-2] at the end of the markupid ...

I want to do the same but i don't know how...


Hey Alex,

Beans sub-filters are perfect for that (read documentation here). So if you are using beans_open_markup() and beans_close_markup(), you can add sub-filters in between square brakets. Here is an example:

$unique_id = 'unique';

beans_open_markup( "example_item[_{$unique_id}]", 'div', array( 'class' => 'example-class' ) );

 // Some stuff.

beans_close_markup( "example_item[_{$unique_id}]", 'div' );

Then users will be able to add a class to all the example markup as such:

beans_add_attribute( 'example_item', 'class', 'another-class' );

Or target a specific item which would have an id unique for example as follow:

beans_add_attribute( 'example_item[_unique]', 'class', 'another-class' );

This gives users great flexibility and the ability to precisely target markups πŸ™‚

Hope that helps!


Yes, i have understood that, my question was how to set dynamically this unique ID, incrementing it on each new layout.

So it was a pure php question, i already find the solution, so now each new layout i used as builder_text_editor[_numberx] , the number increment each time a layout is used.

It's super cool!


Actually i thought i add the solution, but it still have a problem.

i create this function :

function counter( ) {
 static $count = 0;
  $count++ ;
  return $count;
}

Then i do that

$number = counter();

echo beans_open_markup('builder_text_editor[_'.$number.']','div',array('class'=>'uk-container uk-container-center uk-margin-large'));

It works if the elements are on the same page, but if elements are on different pages, then the counter is reset... i use this in a template page, perhaps it's for that...

I could use a custom field to set the unique id, but i really would like to have it setup dynamically


Hey Alex,

I doubt you need to build a counter, I am pretty sure that Carbon Fields->Complex Fields are using unique ids or integer.s Since they are re-usable, they have to be registered them in a unique way. Use what ever Carbon Field uses to make Complex Fileds unique to set your Beans Markup. It goes hand in hand πŸ™‚

Happy coding,


Hi, This is clever but i don't see any id or integer in the ccomplex field, perhaps i will ask to them, they are very supportive. Anyway for the moment i have solved it putting a custom field, and perhaps it's the best solution as being able to put a true word for a filter is better than a number, and with that i can also setup multiple filters. The more i dig in beans , the more i discover things πŸ™‚


Hey Alex,

What I mean is that when you retrieve the complex fields using carbon_get_post_meta(), it returns an array of key values since it can be used multiple times. You could use the array keys to set your sub-filters. That said it is not something I would really advise as it may lead to use quite a bit of PHP memory and since the array items will depend on the user entries, the sub-filters will be subject to change which isn't a good idea! I can't think of a better solution since you are trying to add sub-filters for dynamic values though.

Hope that helps,


Thank you Thierry,

I will still with the custom fields !

Write a reply

Login or register to write a reply, it's free!